I will be traveling on a TWA fly free voucher to the Caribbean, and am looking for suggestions on a destination. My options follow:

*Puerto Rico
*St Thomas
*Tortola
*Virgin Gorda
*St Maarten
*St Croix
*Dominican Republic
*Aruba

My needs are for an inexpensive, not overly-touristed destination where I can enjoy myself without feeling like I was in Cancun. I also do not wish to spend time in a place with huge cruise ships docking and bringing flocks of pasty, white Americans with too much money and an excessive appetite for rum.

Any feedback is greatly appreciated.

Cheers.